What Do You Do When Your Child Can’t Win By the Rules Everyone Else Is Using?

The playground teaches kids that winning belongs to whoever is bigger, faster or louder. There is another option nobody mentions: change the game.

Share
A cheetah, a hawk-headed runner and a kangaroo crouch at a starting line beside one small worried boy.
He is not going to win this. That is information about the race.

Some kids are told, directly or not, that winning belongs to whoever is strongest, fastest, or loudest in the room. If your child is not any of those things, that message can land as “I don’t get to win.” There is another option nobody mentions: invent a new game, one where the old rules do not apply at all.

What “Solving” Actually Means for a Child Who Won’t Win the Usual Way

Solving means inventing a new answer when the old one does not fit. Not fighting harder inside someone else’s rules, but noticing the rules themselves and building something they never accounted for. It is the payoff of everything this month has built toward: seeing clearly, interpreting accurately, and holding steady, all put to use.

Why “Different” Can Be the Whole Strategy

  • Someone who thinks they know everything has a specific weakness. They have stopped expecting to be surprised. That is exactly where an unexpected move works best.
  • A child who cannot out-muscle a problem can often out-think it. And out-thinking does not require being bigger, older, or louder than anyone in the room.
  • “The right question, prepared in advance, can stop someone who won’t listen” is a different message from “just try harder.” One is a tool. The other is a demand.

One Thing I Learned

Janice Lawrence reading one of her storybooks to a small child in a yellow armchair.
Raising three very different children taught me that the rules don’t work for everyone. Sometimes the rules themselves are the problem.
My children didn’t succeed because they became better at someone else’s game. They succeeded when they found a different way to play.
Sometimes the smartest move isn’t trying harder. It’s changing the game.

Try Naming This With Your Child Today

Ask your child to name one person or situation where the usual rules do not seem to work in their favor. Then ask a different question than usual: not “how do you win that,” but “what’s one thing they’d never expect you to do?” That reframes the whole problem.

Meet the Girl Who Out-Thought a King Who Knew Everything

This is the skill I built the final story of the month around. The Clever Girl Fools the Fairy King is the fourth of four illustrated fairy tales in my Clever Girl series — each comes with a Playbook, a companion activity book kids do on their own after the story, no reading required.

In this book, the Clever Girl does not win with strength or magic. She wins because the Fairy King believes he knows everything, and she finds the one question he cannot answer, to save her father.

Watch The Clever Girl Fools the Fairy King Read-Along video for FREE! Opens in a new window. Story Coach members watch ad free.

Today’s Free Activity: Words That Win

A two-page printable. On the first page a child looks at what helped the Clever Girl trick the Fairy King. On the second, they name a difficult person from their own life and invent the one question that person could never answer.
Free printable, two pages. It ends with a question of their own.

Your child first looks at what helped the Clever Girl trick the Fairy King, and notices that no single piece worked alone.

Then they name one difficult person from their own life, and think of the one question that person could never answer. That second page is the whole point.

Download Words That Win activity for FREE! Two pages. No email, no sign-up.

Does This Sound Like Your Child?

This activity helps all kids build strategic thinking through story. It is especially good for children who have:

  • Shame — kids who have absorbed the idea that the smart way to win is not available to them. This activity hands them a different definition of smart.
  • Anxiety — kids who freeze when a problem feels too big to face head-on. Sidestepping a problem, rather than confronting it, is sometimes the calmer path.
  • Social Delays — kids who struggle with direct confrontation but plan carefully when given time and space to think it through first.
  • Autism Spectrum — kids who reason exceptionally well about systems and rules, and who can spot a rule’s blind spot faster than most, once shown how.

It Doesn’t Stop at the Fairy King

The Clever Girl covered head to foot in honey and feathers, shaking out two pillows.
The Clever Girl changes the rules.
  • This is the whole month, converged. Seeing what is really there, interpreting what someone believes against what is true, holding steady under pressure — all of it feeds this final skill: inventing an answer nobody expected.
  • This is what “visual superpowers” actually means. Not a love of pictures. A real, teachable way of solving problems that does not depend on being the strongest voice in the room.

Try It This Week

Cover of The Clever Girl Fools the Fairy King by Janice Lawrence, showing the Clever Girl and the Fairy King inside a painted border of flowers and small characters.
The Clever Girl Fools the Fairy King
  • Download Words That Win and work through both pages together.
  • Ask the “what would they never expect” question about one real situation this week.
  • If the leap to a new question feels too big, stay inside the story. “Who made the plan? Who asked the question? Who couldn’t answer it?” Then let your child finish: “The Clever Girl won because she ___.”

One activity is a sample. A month is a curriculum.

Story Coach opens all sixty learning activities for the current character month, that month’s Grown-Up Guide, and every read-along ad free — and you can print as much as you need for the children in your own care.
See what Story Coach includes — $9/month

Stop ’n’ Think

What rule has your child been trying to win that was never designed for them in the first place?

Learn More

If this sounded like your child, these are worth your time.
Helping Kids With Flexible Thinking
Child Mind Institute — The clinical name for what the Clever Girl does. Kids who struggle here freeze, or try the same failing strategy over and over. The fix is asking what else could be tried — which is the question this activity ends on.
Trouble With Flexible Thinking: Why Some Kids Only See Things One Way
Understood — What it looks like from the outside when a child cannot find the second option, and why it reads as stubbornness when it is closer to being stuck. Useful before you ask your child to invent a new rule.